3 risks to reformation, reconciliation and transformation.

nicpaton's picture

With the Amahoro gathering coming up next week, I would like to detail a few thoughts in advance. These pertain to 3 risks we face when attempting to enter the "Reform" space in a post-colonial context.

1 - Missing the Rendezvous
As Africa experiences things the West is (to some extent) moving beyond (economic progress, individual freedoms, increased literacy, digital technology, consumerist opportunity) and starts to occupy the space vacated, the West rediscovers connectedness, cosmology, and relationship, which is read by many Africans as the old ways which have held them back. The meeting point can be missed because we do not find the right trajectory, the right combination or emphasis of potentially sharable values.

2 - A new, improved patrony
"The great, and I presume also good, white chief sends us word that he wants to buy our lands but is willing to allow us to reserve enough to live on comfortably. This indeed appears generous, for the red man no longer has rights that he need respect, and the offer may be wise, also, for we are no longer in need of a great country." [Chief Seattle]

That the new conversation does not result in true equality and exchange, but an enlightened version of colonial assumptions. Where Africans, enamored by generous and enlightened westerners, compromise their values in order to be accepted by or benefit from them. Where the westerners get the feelgood factor from the exchanges but do not maintain or build lasting relationships.

Brian McLaren reminds us of an American movement who sought to publically apologise to the Native peoples, but ended up causing more harm than good because the Natives had expected friendship to result but this was not forthcoming; what that movement really wanted was the spectacle of repentance.

3 - Misunderstanding glocal balance
"To be African does not mean being in prison in Africa." [Manu Dibango]

While some (including most Africans) experience life in and bound to the local and the particular: village, tribe or ecosystem for example, others who have opportunity to travel think more globally. When individuals start to differ from their home cultures, they can become ostracised. The broader vision is rejected at the local level. Those who live or think globally can miss the points of access into particular communities. Locals can undervalue their heritage, their deep knowledge of their own cultures traditions, their land and their ancestry.

For reformation, both sides need to revision:
- Africa needs to question its rush into prosperity, consider the power of its own traditions, and develop a critique of the modern assumptions handed them via colonialism.
- Post modern Westerners intent on transformation need to grasp these same values as well, communicating them to their own culture, and at the same time developing the empathy and space, whereby Africans can feel truly hosted and accepted on their own terms.

Comments

Roger Saner's picture

The Hitchhiker's Guide to Amahoro

I've just put the Amahoro programme online here - I'm very excited to see the diversity of people who will be attending and what will come out of it.

You raise some good thoughts here, Nic. What we need is friendship with the 'other' which means risk, and moving beyond our familiar circles (and doing that is difficult). No easy solutions...

Steve Hayes's picture

The uninformative Amahoro web site

Just had another go at the Amahoro web site...

Tried to register for information again, got:

Incorrect form submission, use POST

Tried the contact form, got

Incorrect form submission, use POST

Strill could find no information on WHERE IT IS and HOW TO GET THERE.

Does anyone know?

Can anyone tell me?

Text kept getting covered by pictures - incredibly badly designed web site, and frustrating to the user

Thanks to Roger for making the information accessible, because the organisers certainly aren't.

.

Steve Hayes's picture

Amahoro

Hi Roger,

Thanks for putting the programme on your site. I can't afford the whole thing, but might manage a day -- the Tuesday programme looks most interesting.

Can you tell us where it is and how to get there?

I looked at the Amahoro web site, but couldn't find that information anywhere.

It had a form to fill in for information, but it didn't like that either, and when I tried to submit it dropped the page and gave an error message.

Steve Hayes's picture

Amahoro conference

Nic,

I hope to be able to go on Tuesday, because the programme looks most ineresting to me -- especially Keynote 1 -- "What is postcolonialism and why does it matter?"

That's the question I've been asking for some time, but answers are hard to come by, so I hope that I will then have a better idea of what it's all about.

The one on the TRC also looks interesting - a sort of how to move from the past to the future thing.

I realise that this doesn't respond to any of your points, but I suppose we each have our own expectations and hopes for such things.

Roger Saner's picture

Recommendation

If I were to recommend the best talk at the conference, it would be Kenzo Mabiala. He absolutely blew me away with his talk which opened Amahoro 2007 in Uganda - African Postcolonial Theology: the imperative to differ. He's a theologian who did his doctorate under D.A. Carson, he is a scholar who understands postcolonialism, and he wove theology and postcolonialism together in such a way that left me breathless. It's one of the 3 best talks I've heard in my life.

nicpaton's picture

mabiala soundbytes

(Roger - tell me if this is indeed "Mabiala Justin-Robert Kenzo, GTh, MDiv., PhD." according to the website of FACULTE DE THEOLOGIE EVANGELIQUE DE BOMA , else I shall remove his picture)

But here are some snippets from his talk:

  1. Identity is not inherited, it is created.

  2. Postmodern critique of the enlightnment is as relevant to Africa as it is to the West.

  3. To me, modernity means slavery, colonialism, and apartheid.

  4. (Senghor) The West reduces the other to an object to analyse and dissect, which kills the otheness of the other and reduces it to sameness. In Africa, the other is communed with.

  5. "Affective" rationale - your presence is a blessing to me.

  6. Postmodernism creates that space where the original, the contextual, the local, is valued.

  7. If we remain in a modern paradigm, everything has to be universal; we [can't] do African worship or theology ..


I love numbers 2 and 6, and I hope he comes to my defense when I start explaining why a critique of post moderism is revelant across the board.

But as far as his assertion that "In Africa, the other is communed with" well he shall have to explain the evident tribalism and confromity apparent in African Culture to make it ring true.

Roger Saner's picture

That's Kenzo!

Yes, that's Kenzo - and I'm completely unsure as to which order his names come in. When I first read about him, it was "Mabiala Kenzo" but everyone seems to call him by his first name, Kenzo. This is an unfathomable, indeterminate mystery.

While Kenzo isn't a post-modern, he is sympathetic (much to the consternation of his thesis advisor, D.A. Carson) because the emerging church conversation is asking good questions - the kind of questions Kenzo would want asked of Western Christianity, and of Western theology (which came of age during the rise of colonialism).

He also likes whiskey.

Marius Brand's picture

Dear Steve...

My sincere apologies for your difficulties with the Amahoro website. I have nothing to do with its design or maintenance so I am afraid I cannot help with that. But as local organiser, I can tell you that the Gathering is being held at the Youth For Christ Training Centre (Bekker School Road, Hekpoort, Magaliesberg). You can find a map to get there at: http://www.yfc-cyara.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=54&Itemid=73

If you email me at marius@amahoro-africa.org I can send you all the info you need in pdf format (which will be much better for your blood pressure than trying to navigate the website!).

The cost for a day visitor is R200 p/d, but you need to let me know asap when you are coming as I need to give the venue final numbers tomorrow!

The first keynote address on post-colonialism will be well worth your while - the speaker, Kenzo Mabiala, is a theologian/philosopher from the DRC, who gave up his position as professor at a prominent university in Canada to run a small seminary in the DRC. In other words, he practices what he preaches!

Steve Hayes's picture

Thanks!

Thanks Marius!

I was beginning to think the venue was a secret, like one of those computer games where you have three doors to open, and one has the map, another a poisoned spear that jumps out at you, and the third a hungry dragon.

andrew's picture

Space in my car...

Jeremy Barty and I will be arriving at Lanseria Airport on Tuesday at 8:15 from CPT. We will be driving through to Amahoro and staying overnight on Tuesday. We are be returning to Lanseria on Wednesday afternoon.

If anyone keen to catch a lift with us, call me on 083 4148466

Blessing
Andrew

Andries Louw's picture

The African Reformation

Thank you for starting the conversation in advance. Looking forward to meeting everybody there! Here is my introduction:

http://nextchurch.wordpress.com/2009/06/08/amahoro-africa-conference-the-african-reformation/

Andries Louw
http://nextchurch.wordpress.com

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <em> <b> <img> <i>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options